Navigating the Transition to Supervisor

Published On: April 17, 2024By Categories: Business Management, People at Work

Taking on a leadership role involves a learning process for everyone at a company.

By Alexandra Walsh

Transitioning from peer to supervisor can be difficult, especially if the supervised team is full of former peers.

Some new supervisors may not have the tools to successfully transition, setting them up for potential failure. It’s an unnecessary risk in today’s workforce of high turnover and disengaged employees.

Transitioning from coworker to supervisor changes dynamics. As a leader, the supervisor works to support their team members and oversee that they are meeting their goals. The supervisor should evolve into a good role model who is willing to give advice and feedback.

New supervisors should ease into the transition by taking time to communicate one-on-one with their team members to explain how they plan to manage each person’s work responsibilities and help them set goals.

They should treat their team members equally and give everyone a fair chance to prove they have the skills to excel in their roles. When assigning work or giving performance reviews, the supervisor should be as objective as possible and strive to be an ethical leader.

When starting out in their new role, there is a lot for a supervisor to learn, and they need the training materials from their predecessor or person overseeing the company’s human resource efforts. If they accept this role before their previous supervisor moves on, they can do hands-on training with the departing supervisor. This way, they will feel prepared to fully take on their new leadership position.


The transition from an employee to a supervisor is both exciting and challenging. Here are some other common challenges new supervisors may encounter during the transition.

Establish Authority

As a new supervisor, gaining the respect and trust of the team is crucial. Some employees may question the new supervisor’s leadership abilities, especially if they were promoted within the same team. Demonstrating confidence, competence, and equity to establish authority effectively is essential.

Balance Friendliness and Professionalism

Striking the right balance between being approachable and maintaining professionalism can be tricky. Building positive relationships with team members is important, but equally important is maintaining a level of professional distance to make impartial decisions.

Deal with Conflict

Conflict resolution becomes a more significant part of the job for a supervisor. Handling disagreements and disputes among team members or between employees and management requires strong communication and interpersonal skills.

Manage Performance

Evaluating and managing the performance of their team members may be new to the supervisor. Addressing underperformance or delivering constructive criticism can be challenging, especially if the supervisor was previously a peer with their team members.

Manage Time

Supervisors’ roles often include additional responsibilities and tasks. Balancing administrative duties, team management, and working on their own projects can be challenging.

Handle Stress and Pressure

For the supervisor, meeting tight deadlines or making difficult decisions can be highly stressful. Learning to cope with stress and effectively manage pressure is essential for maintaining a personal mental outlook and a healthy work environment.

Delegate Effectively

Learning to delegate tasks appropriately and trusting their team to complete them can be a challenge for new supervisors, who may feel the need to oversee everything.

Align with Organizational Goals

Understanding and aligning the team’s objectives with the company’s broader organizational goals is crucial. New supervisors may need time to fully absorb the company’s vision and strategic direction.

Learn Continuously

Transitioning to a supervisor role requires ongoing learning and development to improve leadership skills, stay updated on best practices, and adapt to changing circumstances.

Leadership Skills

Leadership roles demand self-awareness, being adaptable, and a willingness to learn from successes and challenges. The following are steps to help make the supervisor’s transition successful.

As a supervisor, they must lead and inspire their team effectively, and take the time to develop leadership skills such as communicating, decision-making, problem solving, and delegating. New leaders should consider training opportunities, read books or articles on leadership, or observe and talk with experienced supervisors about what has worked for them in their careers.

Establish Boundaries and Maintain Professionalism

It’s essential to set clear boundaries with former peers and maintain a professional demeanor. While they can still be friendly and approachable, a balance must be established between being a friend and being a supervisor. And, of course, supervisors should avoid office gossip and be circumspect about sharing their personal matters with their team members. This will help ensure respect and avoid potential conflicts.

Adapt to New Responsibilities

Moving into a supervisory role requires new responsibilities and a shift of focus from primarily completing tasks to overseeing the work of others. Providing support and resources so team members can effectively operate should be one of the supervisor’s key responsibilities. They can create a plan to delegate tasks effectively, set performance expectations, and provide constructive feedback. They can also seek guidance from experienced supervisors or their own manager to navigate these new responsibilities.

Align Expectations and Realities

The transitioning supervisor should be transparent about their role as a supervisor while understanding the capabilities and limitations of their team members. The supervisor and team members should work together to establish realistic goals and communicate openly about progress and challenges. The supervisor should take time to conduct regular one-on-one meetings with their team members to discuss their goals and career aspirations. They should be open and transparent about the company’s expectations for performance and how it aligns with individual team members’ plans.


Becoming a supervisor is a major career change. Asking for feedback from their team members can help a new supervisor learn their strengths and weaknesses as a leader.

A supervisor in their first leadership position should meet with other leaders to get their advice. They should ask important questions that will benefit their transition, learn what others considered their biggest struggles as a leader, and hear what others wished they had known when they took on their positions.

Building a support system is essential to a successful transition for supervisors in a new role.

Alexandra Walsh is the vice president of Association Vision, a Washington, D.C.–area communications company. She has extensive experience in management positions with a range of organizations.

Read the Current Issue

you might also like